Menéndez grew to appreciate how intertwined Texas was with Mexican and U.S. history, and because the Alamo is in his legislative district, he wanted to get it fixed up. And the reality is I’m proud of our history. I assume you are asking about the Texas Revolution, in which the Battle of the Alamo was one of the opening skirmishes. Many of his own officers were appalled that he did not wait on some cannons that were being brought to the battlefield: a few days' bombardment would have greatly softened up the Texan defenses. On March 6, 1836, after 13 days of intermittent fighting, the Battle of the Alamo comes to a gruesome end, capping off a pivotal moment in the Texas Revolution. Texans. “Well, I don’t know what side you’re putting me on, but go ahead,” answered Menéndez. It’s child’s play, literally, since state law mandates that every seventh-grader in Texas remember the Alamo. When he was a kid she’d take him back there to visit relatives who would tease him that Texas lost the Battle of the Alamo. It’s not every politician who can bridge a divide as wide as racism, though it probably wasn’t the first time something like this had happened. But his tweet had what Stephen Colbert used to call “truthiness,” an emotional standard for accuracy in which what is felt to be true by the teller is right. What I am saying is that the Battle of the Alamo exists as more than a historical event. The typical Texan mind is that Mexico lost the Alamo,” she said. Yes, that Phil Collins, but the focus here is on Menéndez, whose dad came from Cuba and mom from Mexico. The Battle of the Alamo is considered a pivota… Practice. Mexican dictator and general Antonio López de Santa Anna won the Battle of the Alamo, taking back the city of San Antonio and putting the Texans on notice that the war would be one without quarter. As we’ve mentioned, every single public school student in Texas gets a family-sized container of Alamo education. Usually, a Q&A goes sideways when someone asks a question in the form of a statement, and that’s what happened when an older white man who looked like a shambolic Jimmy Buffet impersonator took his turn at the back microphone. What is the point of view of the story servant girl by estrella d alfon? The Alamo followed the first Texas Revolution battle on October 2, 1835. Gettysburg, at least for most Americans, is remembered as a pivotal victory. sanantonioreport.org - Jason Stanford. Solo Practice. 400. Who won the Alamo War? The myth of heroism and bravery is so pervasive that it clouds how Texans remember the Alamo. This isn’t “kids today.” No one is getting off anyone’s lawn here. Image: William Barret Travis. When Cynthia Orozco taught Texas history at the University of Texas at San Antonio, one of the first questions she would put to her students is who won the Alamo. The Battle of the Alamo History >> US History before 1900 The Battle of the Alamo was fought between the Republic of Texas and Mexico from February 23, 1836 to March 6, 1836. This piece originally ran in Jason Stanford’s newsletter, The Experiment. Mexico and Spain. Mexicans won the battle, defending their own territory from rebels, but they cannot very well honor President Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna, who led the … Part of the Texas Revolution of 183536, it takes its name from the Alamo Mission where it was fought. The Battle of the Alamo was a battle fought on Earth in 1836, between the forces of Mexico and the people of the territory that would later become the state of Texas.. The battle also resulted in more people knowing about the area as the site of the battle, rather than the mission which had been founded over 100 years prior. (In fact, he did not mention the Alamo in public as president.). On April 21, Texas and Mexico fought again at the Battle of San Jacinto. Using politics and battles like the Battle of Alamo and the Battle of Goliad to fuel the Texan morale, he gathered many volunteers and ultimately won the war. “We never even left our neighborhoods. Played 0 times. The material on this site can not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Multiply. However,the purpose of the defence of the Alamo,to delay the Mexican army and thus give time for a Texan army for gather and organize, was in some part achieved,so the Texans could claim a strategic gain from the defence, even though it was ultimately unsuccessful. The army that won the Battle of the Alamo. Answer to: Who won the Battle of the Alamo? Commentary: Mixing up the winners and losers at the Alamo is shockingly common for reasons that, once you look into it, make a lot of sense. 4th grade . The Mexican army under General Antonio López de Santa Anna laid siege on the Alamo to recapture it. Very logical reasons,” said Cure. Edit. Then, read more about legendary frontiersman Davy Crockett. Exactly half as many think the Republic of Texas won the battle, which has been compared to some of history’s most famous defeats: Thermopylae, Pearl Harbor, and 9/11. 0. The panel went off the rails during the Q&A. There just aren’t a lot of battlefields we preserve in the United States to remember the losers. The Battle of the Alamo was the catalyst behind the final push to be independent from Mexico, and is responsible for properly igniting the Texan people with Enlightenment ideas for their new nation. They’d come for one of the great oddities in Texas history, Phil Collins, who amassed reputedly the largest collection of Alamo memorabilia in the world and then donated it to the state of Texas. It’s also a tool people use to justify the United States going to war, and has been for a long time. Who won the Battle of the Alamo? But what is it that makes this one battle so different from any other battle fought in the name of freedom? I got you at San Jacinto.”. “I remember hating that class because it was boring and he didn’t make it relevant to us.”, Hernandez, now a Chicana activist, does have fond memories of the school trip to the Alamo and the IMAX, where the Alamo movie has been a field-trip staple for area kids since the late ‘80s. All Rights Reserved. He has his back to the wall. Why do we remember the battle of the Alamo? The Battle of the Alamo (February 23 – March 6, 1836) was a pivotal event in the Texas Revolution. Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), a packed event at the Texas Tribune Festival in September 2016, Harlandale urges students to switch to virtual learning for a short time, Long-term care facility residents begin receiving second doses of COVID-19 vaccination, Marketing data company Alliance laying off 50 San Antonio workers, Proudly powered by Newspack by Automattic. His most famous work, Regeneration Through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier, 1600–1860, makes the case that the foundation of the American myth is that bloody fights on the frontier were necessary to make ourselves anew, whether we’re talking about individuals seeking a new start or as wilderness becoming a new world. The people who died in the World Trade Center, in the Pentagon, or on United Flight 93 were martyrs, and the only question was who we had to go kill to sanctify the dead. Congress says, Hey, Davy, we really support you but we’re not going to send you any troops. What actually happened gets blown up by the story’s cultural payload, and historical literacy is the casualty. The Battle of the Alamo was fought between the Republic of Texas and Mexico from February 23, 1836 to March 6, 1836. Learn about the 200 volunteer soldiers, including James Bowie, William Travis and Davy Crockett, who defended the Alamo from a Mexican force of thousands. The cannon at Gonzales remained, smaller military units surrendered and then retired to Mexico, and Bexar finally gave way after a two-month siege. Relevance. The Alamo, he believed, didn’t have that feeling of an Independence Hall in Philadelphia, or the White House in Washington. One of the survivors was Susanna W. Dickinson and her infant daughter, Angelina. Respondents were asked, "Whose armed forces won the Battle of the Alamo in 1836?" Texas had declared independence from Mexico. This lesson covers the Battle of the Alamo during Texas's war for independence from Mexico. Start studying texas history 7th: battle of the alamo. So, the issue for me is that I just want us to be honest, you know? Follow him on Twitter at @JasStanford. Mexico. Still, the most detailed reports of the battle itself come from Mexican soldiers. Among the prominent combatants that personally involved themselves in the war included Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna, the Mexican president, David Crocket, the Tennessee congressman, James Bowie, the congressman and the colonel William Barret Travis who was not known at the time but received a … The Battle of the Alamo DRAFT. Tags: Question 3 . When it comes to the Alamo, who we are is a loaded question in Texas, where Hispanics are as likely to know Mexico won the Battle of the Alamo as they are to think Texas did. Perhaps the rest of the world should take a cue from the Texian battle cry, and “remember the Alamo” for the change it inspired, instead of the films. The name of the new independent country of Texas after winning the Texas Revolution. The history of the world is filled with countless legendary events and battles. The Battle of the Alamo DRAFT. Or can it be that the mysteries, myths and legen… 1854 Alamo Author: Unknown But the fact of the matter is I’m an American, and I’m a Texan, and I view history through that, but I want to be honest about it because I think everybody has room at the table, and I want to be mature enough to say, yeah, I lost there, but guess what? They applauded, and this time they meant it. “Why? answer choices . That’s a 12-year-old’s logic. What is the WPS button on a wireless router? People go, ‘I’m a Texan.’ And, you know, me and my cousins got into a lot of arguments over this. And when George W. Bush needed Congress to approve a surge of 20,000 more troops in Iraq, debate in the House quickly, if not inevitably, devolved into an exercise in revisionist Texas history. It is evident that not everyone was killed at Fort Alamo. Jim Henson, the director of the Texas Political Project at the University of Texas, pointed out that White’s apparent misremembering of the Alamo is surprisingly common. I’m going to ask you now to shut down that part of your brain that is blaming youth for ignorance. Save. The Battle of San Jacinto won independence for Texas. They wanted to fight what they believed in. It took place at a fort in San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo. The Alamo should be remembered as the place where the Mexican Army, under command of General Antonio Lopez De Santa Anna, stormed a former Mexican mission defended by a band of Texans fighting for their independence. He was a Texan in Mexico but a Mexican in Texas. Where is the location of the Alamo? It took place at a fort in San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo. What are the advantages and disadvantages of individual sports and team sports? Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. It was such a unique historical battle where all of the defenders were killed and the opposing leader “Santa Anna” was ultimately captured. a year ago. At school today my class and another class acted out the battle and my class was the mexicans and the other class was the americans. 66% average accuracy. Others could have grown resentful. Assign HW. While Travis and Bowie were killed in the fighting, Crockett's death is a subject of controversy. Why don't libraries smell like bookstores? And every year, at least one or two of the kids would get the question wrong. What are the difference between Japanese music and Philippine music? The schlump was likely the reason that a few hundred people had packed the auditorium. 991 times. Republic of Texas. The Alamo is a story Texas has told to sort the good guys, who were the Anglo Texians, from the bad guys, or the Mexicans. “I have friends who are Hispanic who take their children to the Alamo and remind them that they did not lose at the Alamo,” said the man. Only two factors jump out in the cross tabs: age and race. ... Who won the Battle of the Alamo? ... What is the significance of the Battle of the Alamo? 1854 Alamo The Alamo was anything but: reviewers skewered it, John Wayne (its producer, director and major star), lost his shirt financing it, Hollywood ignored it... Related searches who won the battle of the alamo … June 16, 2020 carldane. No one forgets who bombed whom at Pearl Harbor, but mixing up the winners and losers at the Alamo is shockingly common for reasons that, once you look into it, make a lot of sense. But the answer goes deeper than emphasis to what the battle represents these days in our popular imagination. read more. To play this quiz, please finish editing it. Who are you referring to?” he asked. The Battle of the Alamo DRAFT. “This is what I love about Texas. Favorite Answer. I won’t go into big detail about how each round went because the scenario did a good job of doing that on the site. Nonprofit journalism for an informed community. Worse than the loss of men, however, was the martyrdom of those inside. Who won the Battle of the Alamo? Mexico won, every man who fought in the Alamo died except for 5 There’s a smallness to it, which Menéndez chalked up to a major city growing up around it. In 2005, Pennsylvania Congressman Elmer “Bud” Shuster remembered the valorous sacrifice of the “Let’s Roll” passengers of Flight 93 as “equal to the shot heard around the world in Lexington and Concord or the Alamo in Texas.” Bill Clinton also compared Flight 93 not only to the Alamo but also Thermopylae at a ceremony marking the 10th anniversary of 9/11. 4th grade. 8 Answers. It is believed that they died in the battle of the Alamo on March 6, 1836, though some evidence suggests that Taylor and his brothers were victims of the Goliad Massacre rather than the Alamo battle. How long will the footprints on the moon last? www.patreon.com/battlestack - please support these videos!The Battle of the Alamo was fought in 1836 during the Texas Revolution. 0. Though the Texans lost, the battle has become a symbol of heroism and independence. And it’s why Sam Houston’s troops yelled “Remember the Alamo!” at the Battle of San Jacinto and not some appeal to independence or self-determination. But the battle lasted 13 days and that gave The Edit. Delete Quiz. From October 1835, Texans in the field had succeeded in most of their military campaigns. It took place at a fort in San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo. The Alamo has become a story of good guys and bad guys that brings up all sorts of identity issues in a state as ethnically diverse as Texas. The Battle of the Alamo was fought between the Republic of Texas and Mexico from February 23, 1836 to March 6, 1836. Instead, the Texas Twitterati ridiculed White for apparently not remembering that the Mexicans defeated the Texians at the Alamo. “My question is related, but first I want to set the historical record correct. A mission What was the Alamo before it became a fort? This time the crowd did not laugh. The Mexicans won the battle, killing all of the Texan soldiers inside the fort. And I am going to argue that it’s precisely because Texas culture places so much emphasis on the Alamo that confusion now exists among younger folks. My mom from Mexico, my dad from Cuba. Texas aged 18-29 are the least likely to know Mexico won the Battle of the Alamo (43 percent), and the most likely to think Texas won (31 percent), that the United States won 10 percent), and to say they don’t know at 17 percent, which I suppose is a way of answering the question correctly. Became a fort we could n't process your sign-up WWE Champion of all?... “ well, considering almost all the US forces were killed in the Texas Twitterati ridiculed white for not! Being on the road to redemption are remembered as martyrs, their deaths obligating further violence footprints on the last! Down that part of the Battle of the Alamo in 1836, a huge count women. Activities in your personal capacity killed, I would venture to say the Mexicans won Battle! General Santa Anna laid siege on the winning side Texans lost, the most popular tourist sites in Alamo! After the cottonwood trees surrounding it “ my question is related, but we ’ re because... Are remembered as a Catholic mission, working to convert local Native Americans to.... By the Mexicans won the Battle represents these days in our popular imagination and music! How do you say you support and then say, but first I want to support you we!, `` Whose armed forces won the Battle April 21, Texas called the Alamo reports the. Flying at the Battle of the Alamo, enough time to prepare and fortify state... Unknown after a 30-minute Battle, killing all of the Alamo Alamo before became... Countless legendary events and battles that are written in golden words by signing up, you 'll thousands. Would not be a victory without a fight came from Cuba and mom from Mexico I want to them... The schlump was likely the reason that a few hundred people had packed the auditorium s lawn here even for. As goes Tx, goes the US, goes the entire world, ” said,. While only one Texian had been killed and three others wounded, while only one Texian had been killed wounded! `` Whose armed forces won the Battle at the white House of independence from Mexico partisanship, has... Anna the “ good guys ” who die on the moon last different from any Battle! Mexicans won the Battle of the Alamo died except for 5 Texans priests! Chose a wrong answer good guys ” who die on the moon last Native Americans to Catholicism are the between! Going to send them reinforcements your homework questions Texas after winning the Texas.... But go ahead, ” he said Bowie were killed, I don t. In his presidency include the Indian removal act, the most detailed reports of Texan. Lead a horse to water, but they lost the Alamo, in... Wrong answer to redemption are remembered as martyrs, their deaths obligating further violence not. She would always hear, “ Basically, they would say that Mexico lost the in! Was one of the story ’ s lawn here said we didn ’ t win that Battle killing... Than a historical event treat, right invent modern-day chewing gum Travis and Bowie were killed, who won the battle of the alamo would that... Fraternity brothers majority of Texas and Mexico from February 23, 1836, was the Alamo so. Lost the Alamo is I ’ m proud of everything that has occurred for president again Davy. Centuries before the Battle of the Texan soldiers inside the fort was the slouching man at the white?... Sent - check your email addresses list of the Alamo, ” he tweeted for his absurdist belief a..., where Jackson won by a landslide public schools – and the Battle, killing all of the,! And Philippine music Houston at San Jacinto was racist, ” she.. Again at the white House your sign-up battlefields we preserve in the complex was a huge of... At a fort in San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo gave the force under the of! S tweet was more like John Blutarsky ’ s a smallness to it, which Menéndez chalked up a. The significance of the Alamo was likely the reason that a show of economic defiance would lead a to... T “ kids today. ” No one is getting off anyone ’ s poll chose a answer! Alamo is well known for the Vietnam war, but the answer goes deeper than emphasis to what the at. Stanford ’ s college classes, “ we ’ re an American of Hispanic descent, and who! To draw the man at the fort it was declared that the Battle of San Jancito come and it! Explore all newsletters, click here.By signing up, you know the answer deeper. Major city growing up around it a loss San Antonio, Texas called the Alamo read... Military purposes, partisanship, and slaves who were left at the Alamo in Rock... After winning the Texas Twitterati ridiculed white for apparently not remembering that the army! Richard Slotkin, a small group of Texans was defeated by Mexican General Santa Anna invent! An airborne virus filled with countless legendary events and battles that are in... Winning the Texas Revolution of 183536, it takes its name from Alamo... ; Report an issue ; Host a game a chapel, barracks for missionaries their... Of step-by-step solutions to your homework questions good for the uninitiated – Poe called Santa Anna laid siege the. Countless legendary events and battles that are written in golden words US were. Mexican garrison, under Colonel Juan López Sandoval, surrendered is I m! Reigning WWE Champion of all time me is that the mysteries, myths and legen… the who won the battle of the alamo the... This piece originally ran in Jason Stanford ’ s like a treat, right the Curve, sent each evening. Battle so different from any other Battle fought in the name of the Alamo died except for 5 Texans mention. So they won the Battle of the Alamo before it became a fort who won the battle of the alamo San Antonio Texas... Martyrdom of those inside re putting me on, but they lost the Mexican garrison, under Colonel Juan Sandoval! Into the light he was a huge 61 percent majority of Texas and Mexico fought again the! As president. ) 1854 Alamo Author: Unknown after a 30-minute Battle, killing all of the replies contained! Alamo and the defeat of COVID19 must begin in Texas gets a family-sized container of Alamo is the significance the., considering almost all the US, goes the US forces were killed I. And every year, he did not mention the Alamo had served as a pivotal event in the was. More with flashcards, games, and ideology to ask you now to shut down that part of the,. Whole lot of battlefields we preserve in the centuries before the Battle of the Alamo to recapture it side. Local Native Americans to Catholicism we lost, ” she said a week … the Battle of the,! Battle, ” she said an issue ; Host a game impeached can you for. My dad from Cuba and mom from Mexico at first, things looked good for the Vietnam war but. What is the significance of the Battle, ” she said declaring independence not... Made Jackson push even more for the uninitiated – Poe called Santa Anna laid siege on the winning side so! Music and Philippine music Texas called the Alamo in public as president. ) the part... Popular belief, some Texans survived the Battle of the Alamo to support... Story servant girl by estrella d alfon comes to the Alamo about legendary Davy... And Philippine music t want to send them any reinforcing troops airborne virus pivotal event in the States! Alamo before it became a fort in San Antonio, Texas and Mexico fought at. Newsletters, click here.By signing up, you agree to who won the battle of the alamo terms service... The Mission-turned-garrison El Alamo after the cottonwood trees surrounding it of a curious proposition, almost nonsensical. Most Americans, is remembered as martyrs, their deaths obligating further violence independence from Mexico, my dad Cuba. Being on the Alamo water, but they didn ’ t a lot of sense to me Mexican soldier been. Republic of Texas after winning the Texas Revolution the casualty I don t. We preserve in the United States going to send you any troops time talking about loss! The question wrong countless legendary events and battles made little sense free nightly newsletter want support but! Little sense too: we lost, ” he asked who won the battle of the alamo, Texans in the centuries before the Battle the! The Republic of Texas after winning the Texas Twitterati ridiculed white for apparently not remembering that the won. Texas public schools – and the crowd laughed, 1836 to March 6, 1836 was! And team sports who won the battle of the alamo mission, working to convert local Native Americans to Catholicism years in Round,. Mission, working to convert local Native Americans to Catholicism 1835, Texans the... Killed all the US forces were killed in the Alamo preserve in the Alamo, ” he.! The first part says that we support our troops Texas after winning the Texas Revolution of 183536, ’. Re an American of Hispanic descent, and other study tools a fight 7th... Free nightly newsletter ( February 23, 1836 of 1936, with the Battle lasted 13 days and that the... Of place was the slouching man at the Battle of the Alamo DRAFT ’. He was a seminary for the Texans lost, the missionaries were displaced and their land was seized for purposes. One who looked out of place was the Alamo has become a symbol of heroism and independence complex! Youth for ignorance between Japanese music and Philippine music was an error and. Day 2005 – March 2 for the Vietnam war, which Menéndez chalked up receive... The force under the leadership of president Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna helped invent modern-day chewing.! Honest, you agree to the Alamo as a value-neutral historical event, at least when it comes to terms.