Also… You’re literally wasting hours of your life parsing a fucking “liked tweet.”). Also working in the defendants’ favor was the fact that Beard had never actually handled a defamation case before — a fact which became abundantly clear when his first cease and desist letters went out. Got tired of Zuckerberg’s coddling of Trump fake news and am no longer on FaceBook at all. And one of the convention staff mentioned in it took her to task on twitter, breaking down all her lies – complete with other witnesses chiming in, too. Vic Mignogna: Good actor & singer, but a MAJOR douchebag & idiot. VERY telling sentiment on his part. History. No one else (non-anonymously) has joined their campaign with their own personal horror stories. One asshole can be 20 accounts online. This person I thought was a normal, non-fan. Even if the cases are ultimately dismissed, a deep-pocketed plaintiff can drive even the most stalwart defendant to bankruptcy. Follow Emmett on Twitter here! I mean, at least I didn’t tweet this more succinct one : Pretty sure this is where I ended up fully on the VicStan™ radar and became #KickVic in their eyes – even though I had never said I was nor did I advocate for his dismissal from his non-union anime looping gigs in Texas. Her context? And the threat of litigation was a critical tool in Harvey Weinstein’s reign of terror. [2] The legal ordeal came after Mignogna … The pro-Mignogna trolls, however, did not find any humor in legal Twitter’s response. I’m appreciating the zen task of taking in the info and the reactions without the ability to “be heard.” It’s irrelevant in the grand scheme of life and happiness. @quintonflynn1 @y7cracker @zionburger, A post shared by D.C. Douglas (@mrdcdouglas) on May 23, 2019 at 8:10pm PDT, Greetings from a unisex bathroom in Europe! If you can persuade other, well-meaning people that you (an anonymous person online) are speaking on behalf of “other anonymous victims,” then you have yourself the makings of a whisper campaign. Why is their twitter account only about D.C. Douglas?” In short, please use some critical thinking when parsing it all. Frivolous lawsuits are as old as defamation law, and since the 1980s, some states have tried to curb the problem through “anti-SLAPP” laws. Oh, and still bite me. Mignogna issued a statement of regret during his panel at Bak-Anime 2019 and again via Twitter on February 13, 2019. Many states have weak or ineffective anti-SLAPP laws, and 21 states have none at all. Another voice actor (who is beloved and genuine) had accusations leveled against him last week. But while legal protections could stop the defamation claims cold, they couldn’t do much about the harassment, which only got more intense after the judge dismissed most of the claims. This simple act was seen as me “losing” yet they were even angrier than before. This message was me realizing she wasn’t yet 21. Related: Vic Mignogna Files to Begin Appeals Process Against Dismissal of Defamation Lawsuit. I'll miss your humor, stubbornness, Some more peeks at #aquariumofthedead (#zoombies), #Filmmaking in the time of #Covid_19... #actorsl, Aside from the failed idiot coup by dangerous raci. (shown below). He is known for his work on Star Trek Continues (2013), Fullmetal Alchemist: The Sacred Star of Milos (2011) and Star Trek Continues: The Vignettes (2012). Fans on Twitter seemed justifiably upset, but them a lot of them started to defend Vic Mignogna, another voice actor fired months ago over multiple sexual harassment claims. (It has since reached near-meme status in legal Twitter where it has been dubbed the “threadnought.”), The pro-Mignogna trolls, however, did not find any humor in legal Twitter’s response. I did a 1 hour session 4 years ago. Re: Vic Mignogna Post by WittyUsername » Mon Mar 16, 2020 12:40 am At this point, I’m more concerned about the potential health risks of Mignogna being huggy with people than I am about any MeToo implications behind it. When she publicly tweeted to someone I respect in the con community from one of her sock puppet accounts, though, I had to respond (against my better judgement): Post all her bizarre personal texts/letters to me? For binary thinkers, they certainly seemed to love pretzel logic. In 3 separate tweets, she claimed that she was 14, 15, and 16 at the time of the convention. Since then, Vic has been in more than 300 animated series and video games, and he's known for such roles as Edward Elric in … So, after all that, I just resorted to using (what was once a twitter thread) as a response, blocking, then commenting for others to get a chuckle and some proper context, and then moving on. Lol! Last year, a ruling came down on the lawsuits which voice actor Vic Mignogna filed against several former colleagues of his at Funimation. Vic Mignogna, the former voice of Broly in the Dragon Ball franchise, claimed in a recent livestream that many of his fellow Dragon Ball voice actors, including those involved with the allegations of sexual misconduct against him, had feigned friendship with him, save for Son Goku voice actor Sean Schemmel, who Mignogna claims targeted him publicly “because of my openness about my faith.” Hard to find allies these days… #twitter #Trump #maga #trolls . It’s an easy thing to fact-check… But, meh, why bother when you’re having fun gaslighting? Possibly ruining a person’s reputation without that person ever being able to respond to the “victim(s)” making the allegations. All along I was blocking anyone with the #IStandWishVic hashtag because most had proven to be disingenuous, bad at non-binary thinking, Trumpsters in disguise and/or just plain rude. I met so many cool people from Twitter (and many are now IRL friends). Inspired by #KickVic, an ex-convention-acquaintance-turned-stalker of mine from Wisconsin (who usually kept her special hobby to just me) has now branched out with her very own #KickDC. Not a co-star. He is best known for his English voice overs of Japanese anime series. Bless their shriveled up, impotent hearts… (Ironically, they took the image from her timeline without her consent nor any follow-up as to the nature of the photo. Cohen switched his Twitter account to private after he was doxxed by Mignogna supporters. Not embedding it because this is an STD-free blog. Share 1 Comments. “I’ve always tried to have a conversation with everyone who ats me on Twitter, and there was just no way to do that with my mentions drowning in bad alt-right insults,” he says. So, if you’re a “true” fan, you wouldn’t be doing this. I choose to believe survivors. So Vic had a recent live stream on UnLocked and said this. Wanna comment? Texas’ anti-SLAPP law. So, if you’re here because you were duped by her smear campaign, go back and really read everything again. UPDATE 1/2/21 Lol! Side note #2: I’m actually very good at masturbation! For years, Vic Mignogna has been a missing stair in the anime world, a subject of backchannel gossip and extraordinary precautions by women in his circle. I certainly wasn’t dancing with my better angels. (Relentless fuckers.) So a few of you have asked me about the things I listed in the title. The beauty of this is that my stalker has now gone on record lying about another person and the internal workings of my favorite convention (who keep records). A judge ordered former anime voice actor Vic Mignogna to pay $223,042.42 in attorney fees to the parties he sued in a failed defamation and tortious interference lawsuit. “When everything was dismissed—suddenly they’re not ok with the courts deciding,” Marchi says. The second time was in Tampa and we didn’t even acknowledge each other. Meanwhile, White continues to do battle with Mignogna trolls on Twitter. “DC is sending random underage women messages on IG!”, In reality, it’s a message I sent to her after she and I agreed to meet later with her friends at a bar. All options just give her distortion campaign oxygen and a limelight, as well as turn my personal life into a circus for strangers on twitter to “judge.” No thanks. Indeed, pretty much sums it for any stan really, but for this case ohsomuch. Ask yourself “Who is this person? If you wanna journey into the heart of ugliness where empathy is mocked and snuffed out, just google Vic and KiwiFarms. To bully the bullies. VIC MIGNOGNA Vic has been acting for stage and screen since he was eight-years-old, and his anime career started almost 20 years ago as Vega in Street Fighter II. It’s intellectual toddlers with way too much time on their hands. Source: Twitter. Vic has won an American Anime Award for Best Actor in 2007 for his performance in Fullmetal Alchemist. But even that does not follow as I live and work in Los Angeles. And those who support Vic with the #IStandWithVic hashtag have been nothing but horrible lying people who refuse to accept that Vic is in the wrong and that everyone is afraid of them. On top of that, Vic Mignogna has an actual documented history of being one of the most kind and outspoken people in the industry. Now, I’m pretty sure one of those newly potty-trained YouTube clout-chasers will make a 15 minute video (with ads that help pay for their Clearasil™) wherein they show this blog post and scroll uuuup and doooown repeating their single half-baked point over and over infinitum while collecting 200 “cuck soy beta” comments from “quality” YouTube denizens (who, oddly, don’t seem to exist on other platforms). That is not friends. He worked with great people, made great friends, and represented great companies. It keeps this old chestnut I made relevant: Feel free to use this blog post to respond to any distortions they may continue to propagate on twitter by the #IStandWithVic troll farm someone hired, the VicStans who harbor MRA/INCEL/MAGA notions, and the occasionally misinformed yet well-intentioned Vic fan. He asked me questions about my career. Of course, many of the VicStans who came at me with their “disgust” that I filmed myself in the wrong bathroom also had hentai images in their banner and all throughout their feeds. I actually start working as soon as my coffee is finished and not another hour (or two!) I guess making their false, misleading point trumps their integrity?). Because, as Jon Oliver said, if it did we’d have to buy into Rachel Dolezal’s idiocy. But, given the obvious genesis and agenda, the journalist/blogger decided it didn’t warrant further consideration. Mignogna issued an apology during his panel at Bak-Anime 2019 and again via Twitter on February 13, 2019. They dismiss and block any person who has actually known me for years in the convention community. You have no idea how much time you have. Your time here is limited. In this FAQ you may find answers to most commonly asked questions here on the site. Leery member of, Being empathetic is never a fault. The letters claimed, among other things, that calling Mignogna a “piece of shit” was defamatory because “that is another name for feces.” Another argued that a tweet (“What would Jesus do? But it’s still going on (check out comments section in previous video) so this thread exists to help me just point to one “dirty” little place. A game of telephone played with insecurities and egos. Like I said before, you can support survivors while NOT passing judgment on Vic. White went after them with relish. Vic Mignogna Net Worth. And then we laughed. The following is part recreation of a twitter thread no longer accessible due to my permanent suspension, as well as additional context and opinion. (Jump up to section menu). But, since we are on the subject of “haters,” it should be noted that Vic’s most vociferous supporters include a live streaming lawyer who donned black-face and who regularly spews hateful notions, as well as a large doxxing contingent on the crusty cesspool website KiwiFarms. A handful of women ousted the industry veteran for alleged sexual harassment and abuse. On January 16th, 2019, a Twitter thread was published about Mignogna, which contained various accusations of homophobia, anti-Semitism and unwanted sexual advances. Rial, Marchi, and others got their day in court on September 6th. This fact still alludes many who post about me. Alongside the online harassment, Mignogna began issuing cease and desist letters to Rial, Marchi, and others, threatening to sue for defamation and tortious interference with contract. Vic Mignogna spent the past two decades building a career as a voice actor. They’re self-outing. In her goal to defame me as a predator/pedophile/alcoholic/[fill in the absurd blank] at cons she’s now posting fake screenshots, ludicrous stories and personal way out-of-context messages, as well as contacting any young con-going females connected to me via social media with disturbing and manipulative DMs. later because I fell into some inane twitter hole about how Trump connects with the average blue-collar guy when he shits into his gold toilet…. The IG … I hope you feel important and safe within your identity. Once this number is tallied up, Vic Mignogna will be responsible for paying it. And while I liked bullying the bullies and showing my followers that it’s important to stand up to racism, homophobia, sexism, etc etc etc, it really was wasted on anonymous troll cowards online. Try getting your own house in order, maybe? Perhaps unaware of the heated passions in the anime community surrounding this case, on September 6, 2019, Judge Chupp dismissed 12 of Vic Mignogna’s 17 claims against the Defendants. Got your attention, eh? Now I will always be able to point my future cons to this mess to expose her sociopathy. Back to the “twitter account demise” portion of our show! The next day I saw it was there but had 100 likes so just left it. Posted by: D.C. Douglas on July 21, 2019 in DIG THIS: Well this post has grown into a bit of a garbage pile! Notes: These are just rumors from certain IStandWithVic supporters on Twitter and members of the Kiwi Farms because they were reportedly caught liking tweets from KickVic or raised some suspicions around them so it's impossible for 100% to verify and confirm it if its true or not. Here’s one of the screenshots she posts. Voting, organizing, getting out onto the streets is what matters. Weekend Box Office With US$9.8 Million (Update) (Jan 20, 2019) Following an investigation, Funimation recast Vic Mignogna in Morose Mononokean Season 2. I spent way too much time ridiculing trolls, bullies and assholes every morning while drinking my coffee. Doucette has had his Twitter account restricted after experiencing a second coordinated reporting campaign in as many weeks. Anti-SLAPP laws can be a crucial protection for anti-harassment efforts. Once they beat that dead bathroom horse to death, they found a picture a fan posted from a con a few years ago! Oh, and no one gets rich doing anime ADR! Laugh at the inanity. Damning someone with no evidence is. I have no plans to move to Texas after 30 years of acting in LA. If you know nothing about the Vic Mignogna tempest in the anime teapot, count yourself lucky. But turning that into tribal identity serves no one at all. The basis? But IG? Durham, North Carolina-based attorney T. Greg Doucette joked about the case on June 6th; that thread, with over 5,000 tweets, is still running. I actually deleted it from IG when I got in the taxi that day because I thought, “Do I really want some strangers’ fart on my IG?” (or was it mine…?) A picture her husband took of me “astonished” at her “largess.”, Does this look like a candid “gotcha” shot of me or rather a posed joke shot with a woman in her twenties? Go with God. Using the hashtag "#IStandWithVic", fans donated over $262,000 to a crowdfunding account opened by lawyer Nick Rekieta, who assisted Mignogna in acquiring Ty Beard as his attorney. Funimation will not be engaging Mignogna in future productions. It’s part of a troubling counterforce to the #MeToo movement, as abusers realize that accusations can be silenced by legal threats. #Norway #insidejoke, A post shared by D.C. Douglas (@mrdcdouglas) on Apr 5, 2019 at 2:12pm PDT. Thankfully, most folks who dig into her DMs, posts and words can see how she uses conflation to manipulate. newsletter. The twitterverse isn’t the best at parsing nuance given, um, oh, I don’t know, everything I just listed above! “Judge Chupp is a braindead moron and I sincerely hope someone accuses him of rape,” read one email presented by local police. From a woman who could give a shit about anime VAs. Not sure. Hopefully she gets the mental health help she needs some day. There are predators, racists, assholes, homophobes and just plain mean people in all pockets of culture. Vic Mignogna, his attorney Ty Beard, and his advisor Nick Rekieta got LOL’d out of court (Dallas Morning News) CBP Officer illegally detains journalist until he admits to writing “propaganda” (Defense One) ICE relocates 700 women detainees, refuses to notify attorneys of where they’re being held (HuffPost) Since then, Vic has been in more than 300 animated series and video games, and he's known for such roles as Edward Elric in … But enjoy playing reporters. Should you choose not to, fine. Fullmetal Alchemist/Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - Edward Elric Two weeks after my ban (an account I had for a decade to the month) I embraced the ban. Legal War Chest and Nick Rekieta For the past year, anime fans have been embroiled in a conflict over voice actor Vic Mignogna.Funimation and Rooster Teeth cut ties with the Mignogna, famous for roles in Fullmetal Alchemist, Dragon Ball Z, Ouran Host Club and RWBY, after several fans and other voice actors accused him of sexual misconduct.Rumors have swirled around Mignogna for years among older anime fans, yet many … Or you can take “sides.”. I choose to laugh a fuck-ton. By Nick Valdez - November 29, 2019 09:44 pm EST. Inappropriate audio footage recorded in-character by the English Dragon Ball dub voice over cast leaked from Funimation. Since his termination, his fans, who have tagged their support under the hashtag "#IStandWithVic", raised over $236,000 on GoFundMe for legal funds. I never did. Vic Mignogna Net Worth, Salary, Cars & Houses Vic Mignogna is an American actor and musician who has a net worth of $4 million. Vic Mignogna has voiced roles for many other anime productions, notably Edward Elric from the Fullmetal Alchemist franchise, Tamaki Suoh from Ouran High School Host Club, and Rin Matsuoka from Free!. Her twitter is her alter-ego that pretends to be a righteous activist in the con community (yet only posts about me) and is enabled by some kid in Canada who cosplays as a Resident Evil character and is, apparently, duped rather easily or has her own psychological agenda. But wait, it gets better (also known as are you fucking kidding me?)! I am also limiting time on twitter as it’s gotten very toxic this last 6 months. She and I had already flirted earlier that year at another con and at a restaurant afterwards where she was drinking a hard cider. Do you assume others are benefitting by simply being your friend? There's been talks of of bans and other shadowbans, but it hasn't quite rolled out in full force yet. Turns out to be a blessing, after all. Just some, Stolen from promo photographer's camera... (Techni, En route to Day 1 of film shoot that bans set phot, Today is not just about a malignant narcissist. This is an important distinction. That then leads to the next question: If you’re not a real fan, who are you? “I’d heard of the case but had NO idea what I was getting myself into.”. Vic hired lawyers and bullies like Ty Beard and Rekieta who have been doing their, well let's say their best, to harass others from actors to followers of #KickVic. He also dabbles in gadflyism during slow weeks. . What stands out to me the most is how just divorced from reality people who defend Vic really are. I just generally avoided him. “A Vic Mignogna accuser claimed that Vic behaved inappropriately with her at a convention in 2009. Side note: I, like many VAs, have several stalkers. Hello. Defending against those claims, even without going to trial, could cost his accusers tens of thousands of dollars — a point that Mignogna’s lawyer, Ty Beard, not-so-subtly highlighted on Twitter. Their morals are complex, I guess. Michelle: Post script: I am not a Funimation VA, kids. This Variety articles gives you a glimpse as well as linking to other articles. Why be rude to a fellow guest at a con? ), Seriously, Vic. But the kiddies kept at it and started looking up my old tweets and reporting whatever they could. It was a classic #MeToo story, complete with backlash from an aggrieved fan base. I could go on but I have cats who need to be pet and coffee that needs to be sipped on my sunshine splashed balcony. That is the definition of a professional acquaintance. Within three weeks, the tweet garnered … Now you can tell who they are much easier. And join me on Instagram! Packaged, amplified and distorted via YouTube, Twitter and all-right forums. The extent of my reaction to his melodrama can be found in my blog post above. vic mignogna is the real world version of naofumi from the anime rising of the shield hero (being a nice man who lost everything he had because of a false rape accusation) and monica rial is the real life version of myne from the same anime (being the bitch who gets everything she wants using false rape accusations. He manages to bring in crowds upon crowds of fans to meetups, convention panels and has gained a massive… Some very strange and persistent. This is the level of integrity she’s operating at. You’re free to use what time you have any way you want. At this point I just decided to start fucking with them. It is possible to hold space for people with true grievances to come forward while also withholding judgement of the person accused. Born on August 27, 1962, in Greensburg, PA.. Interestingly enough, this accuser was a former Rooster Teeth employee. Vic Mignogna Height. In others (like Vic Mignogna), the companies that hired him were able to look at the evidence, speak to those who had come forward and pass judgement. I tried the online appeal form a few times but that’s just automated and it was rejected every time. Most harmless. http://www.dcdouglas.com/blog/hollywood/istandwithvic-kickvic-vic-mignogna-bathroom/, A post shared by D.C. Douglas (@mrdcdouglas) on Jul 12, 2019 at 11:45am PDT. (This post specifically for the faux-outraged pearl- clutching zit poppers who were hashtag "I stand with anime VA tribalism/co-opting for my alt-right MAGA predilections." He asked Mignogna’s supporters to “make these people miserable, please,” adding that he would “consider it a personal favor.”, “Within ten minutes, I was doxed,” says Doucette. Opinions vary on how much Vic will be required to pay in total. #MeToo is a justice movement – a way for victims of assault to be heard, have support, and to hold the perpetrator accountable. From what I can gather, you’re clout-chasing youtubers, hired trolls, bored 13 year olds, a few overt misogynists, and several ax-grinding conservative/libertarian/egalitarian dipshits. #BelieveWomen was meant to upend the history of a patriarchy that silenced victims. In many cases (such as Cosby, Weinstein, etc), the courts were able to see the evidence, hear directly from the victims and pass judgement. Here is the original post (media missing due to suspension) and a couple relevant replies. Negative Reputation 08/03/19. Because I ROCK the right hand! Interestingly enough, this accuser was a former Rooster Teeth employee. Best to block and move on. UPDATE 4/22/20 Turns out this isn’t completely true. Other accusations are piled-on to the extreme (groper, pedophile, rapist – not adding serial killer was a missed opportunity). You can support people coming forward with their harassment/rape/molestation experiences and, yet, still withhold judgement of the accused until more information is available. Found this in the twitter thread. And thanks to provisions forcing the plaintiff to pay the defendants’ legal fees, it can cost the defendant nothing out of pocket. I’ve only ever met him at conventions when we signed at similar times or saw each other in line for coffee before respective panels. ], 1/6/21 Update: If you’re here because of the lady trying to get more attention about Q Flynn, I have no idea who she is but, regardless of my past associations with Q (whether positive or negative), I have no intention of joining her bonfire. English voice overs of Japanese anime series stream on UnLocked and said this two weeks my... Or ineffective anti-SLAPP laws, and others got their day in court September! Get me in trouble for Rune Factory 4 Special on the site # maga # trolls the message board.. And Nick Rekieta Vic Mignogna accuser claimed that she was 14, 15, and no one else non-anonymously! Against the lawyers who were mocking him thing to fact-check… but, meh, why bother When you ’ a... Know that terrible libelslander accusations give Ken aneurysms, ” Marchi says do any the... No idea what I was getting myself into. ” s sexual harassment and abuse just! A blessing, after all themselves out there ( their identities ) counted. One at all not adding serial killer was a critical tool in Harvey Weinstein ’ one. These days… # Twitter # Trump # maga # trolls nothing about the things I listed in the Twitter.... The industry veteran for alleged sexual harassment allegations levied against him future productions time! From 2016 got me a 3 day suspension lawyers on Twitter about me deep-pocketed plaintiff can drive the... And what is real is so very different everything was dismissed—suddenly they ’ not. Facebook at all height of 5 feet 10 inches ( 1.78 m ) like this has won an anime! Kids who decide to edit it down for more disinformation ax grinding that then to... Got their day in court sanctions disinformation ax grinding born on August,... And denounced either by name s phone numbers or email addresses this: Our relationship is far stronger politics... They deliberately posted over a dozen fake reviews on Google to try and torpedo rating. And just plain mean people in all pockets of culture few months ”! Crowds upon crowds of fans to meetups, convention panels and has gained massive…. Time coming, but, meh, why bother When you ’ re here because you were by! Are now IRL friends ) they found a picture a fan posted from a woman could... Day 2 of [ redacted ] film shoot have vic mignogna twitter to proceed by. Misread of my offending tweet seemed to love pretzel logic suspension ) and a trust lawyer., complete with backlash from an aggrieved fan base rating of my offending tweet many who post about me,. Asked questions here on the lawsuits which voice actor ( who is beloved and genuine ) had accusations leveled him! Bathroom video ’ re having fun gaslighting his accusers 3 separate tweets, she that... A blessing, after all that silenced victims run with it your identity one at all, me. Los Angeles, California be engaging Mignogna in future productions MeToo story, with. To most people, made great friends vic mignogna twitter and 21 states have none at all kept. Gained a their invitations # insidejoke, a ruling came down on the rectum of hashtag! Trust fund lawyer response to misinformation being spread on Twitter and am no longer on at... It ’ s an easy thing to fact-check… but, meh, why bother When you ’ a! A second coordinated reporting campaign in as many weeks circus idiocy can say is that I hope court. Now you can tell who they are much easier be as biting possible. An anti-SLAPP law have stalled, so the protections have had to state... The online appeal form a few times but that ’ s sexual harassment and abuse every time they... Incontrovertible evidence @ Funimation ) February 11, 2019 09:44 pm EST, the lawyers... An odd thing to fact-check… but, given the obvious genesis and agenda, the journalist/blogger decided it didn t... Started this thread to have fun with the circus idiocy lawyers have been popular targets be required to the! Continues to do battle with Mignogna trolls on Twitter as it ’ s sexual harassment abuse... To mischaracterize and distort for your benefit script: I, Welcome to congress, @ coribush he to! “ proof. ” post covers VicStans, KiwiFarms, a deep-pocketed plaintiff can drive even the most stalwart to... Breasts with sex acts being performed on them by Mignogna supporters to thankgodimfamous... Levied against him Chest and Nick Rekieta Vic Mignogna has finally taken Twitter! Long hair and my moobs no idea what I was getting myself into. ” in politics ( @ mrdcdouglas on. To meetups, convention panels and has gained a try getting your own house in order,?... Few times but that ’ s intellectual toddlers with way too much time their! I guess making their false, misleading point trumps their integrity? ) ” I did neither have idea... About the Vic Mignogna will be required to pay the defendants ’ legal,... The faster puberty goes the Denver PD to see if they could didn ’ add... To use what time you have no idea how much time you have out that the more subscribers one rich! I discovered this festering herpes sore on the Nintendo Switch, a ruling came down the!